Bowker and star 1999 sorting things out classification. Sorting things out classification and its consequences geoffrey c. In particular, joanne mccloskey and gloria bulechek provided many helpful suggestions during conversations. Introduction the texture of classification 6 the last chapter examined the detailed interactions among people, institutions, and categories about tuberculosis. To classify is human geoffrey bowker and susan leigh star undertake the challenging and encompassing topic of classification in classification and its consequences. Star and bowker locate their discussion in the wider field of communication. The authors organize their presentation into an introductory chapter that frames the issues, followed by three sections classification and largescale infrastructures, classification and biography, and classification and work practice providing specific examples, and a conclusion section. Bov1ker susan leigh star, fhe mit press cambridge, lvlassachmctts london, england. Apr 02, 2001 once or twice in sorting things out bowker and star muse on the difficulty of classifying their own book on classification. In this paper, i take a long history of databases and databasing technologies over the past two hundred years, discussing the organizational and social dimensions of working with a new information infrastructure. Classification and its consequences until now about the guide we have sorting things out. View the article pdf and any associated supplements and figures for a period of 48 hours. Classification and its consequences stefan helmreich massachusetts institute of technology. Classification and its consequences and the author of memory practices in the sciences, both published by the mit press.
Classification and its consequences, by geoffrey c. Bowker and star 1999 sorting things out classification and its consequ. The things they carried speaking of courage the war was over and there was no place in particular to go. University of california san diego, ca his most recent book, with susan leigh star, is sorting things out. Randall 1 computer supported cooperative work cscw volume 10, pages 147 153. Dsd classification was an attempt at sorting things out bowker and star, 1999, in part through a grounding of the classification system in genetic science. Sorting things out is a sociological work that explains how individuals sort perceived characteristics into categories and the consequences of those choices. On this matter of the power of classification to shape selfidentity, influence work, respond to politics, and in many other ways influence people, sorting things out is unique in its painstaking attention to details and observation of multifaceted causes and effects. But as star and bowker suggest in sorting things out, it is also.
Information management and industrial geophysics at schlumberger, 19201940 geoffrey c. Consequences classification and its sorting things out. Bowker and susan leigh star explore the role of categories and standards in shaping the modern world. Lev manovich has argued that the database is the central symbolic form of our times. Bowker and star sorting things out classification and its consequ. In sorting things out, geoffrey bowker and susan leigh star shed new light on a variety of classification systems and practices. Classification and its consequences inside technology by geoffrey c.
Bowker and susan leigh star this book is a study of classification systems, and information infrastructures that i picked up after reading a description on the redrockeater mailing list. They locate it at the crossroads of the sociology of knowledge and technology, history, and information science p. I argue that this is very much a promissory science hedgecoe, 2004, built upon the expectation that, at. The book describes the evolution and principles of number of signi.
Police were also reported to have examined the private parts of couples and taken people to district surgeons for examination ormond 1986, 33. Classification and its consequences opinions customers are yet to nevertheless still left their report on the overall game, you arent read it still. Standards and classifications produce advantage or suffering. Sorting things out classification and its consequences. Classification and its consequences and the author of memory practices in the sciences, both published by the mit press susan leigh star was doreen boyce chair for library and information science, university of pittsburgh. Geoffrey bowker and susan leigh star, sorting things out. The pdf file you selected should load here if your web browser has a pdf reader plugin installed. All are examples of classification the scaffolding of information infrastructures.
On a personal, professional, or other level, we have all uttered the phrase i have to sort this out. Bowker and susan leigh star, the mit press, 1999 cloth, 2000 paper cambridge. Classification systems and their role in shaping philosophy and social interactions are explored in this unique analysis of human infrastructures. Introduction the texture of classification 6 the last chapter examined the detailed interactions among people. Bowker is professor at the school of information and computer science, university of california at irvine, where he directs a laboratory for values in the design of information systems and technology. They set out to answer what goes into making things seem effortless, who does this work, and what happens to the cases that do not fit. The authors use the international classification of diseases, 9th revision, race classification. Bowker and susan leigh star find, read and cite all.
Each has a trajectory, and the trajectories may pull or torque each other over time if they move in different directions or at different rates. Buyuktur a and bowker g collaborative rhythm proceedings of the acm 2011 conference on computer supported. Our lives are henged round with systems of classification, limned by standard formats, prescriptions, and objects. Sorting things out has a moral agenda, for each standard and category valorizes some point of view and silences another. Stars most celebrated concept was the notion of boundary objects. In the landmark work sorting things out, star and geoffrey bowker revealed the social and ethical histories that are deeply embedded in classification systems. Randall 1 computer supported cooperative work cscw volume 10, pages 147 153 2001 cite this article. In sorting things out, geoffrey bowker and susan leigh star make information infrastructure exciting. Prior to that, bowker was executive director and regis and dianne mckenna professor at the center for science, technology and society at. Bowker and susan leigh star article pdf available in technical communication quarterly 111. Classification and its consequences opinions users havent but quit their own writeup on the overall game, or not make out the print however. Based on analysis of its extensive data resources, bowker provides free annual publishing trend reports such as the annual isbn output report and selfpublishing statistics summary. In a clear and lively style, they investigate a variety of classification systems, including the international classification of diseases, the nursing interventions classification, race classification under.
He is the coauthor with susan leigh star of sorting things out. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form by any electronic or mechanical means including photocopying, recording, or information storage and retrieval without permission in writing from. Bowker and susan leigh star explore the role of categories. In essence, the task of sorting things out, or classifying things, is the subject of this engrossing book. Bowker and susan leigh star, describe how the use of classification influences human. Bowker and susan leigh star, describe how the use of classification influences human behavior towards standardizing the physical world. Here is a real audio interview with geof bowker about classification systems. Classification and its consequences, cambridgemassachusetts, mit press, 2000 1999, 377 pages. Classification and its consequences, cambridgemassachusetts, mit press, 2000 1999.
Bowker and susan leigh star explore the role of categories and standards in shaping the modern. But as star and bowker suggest in sorting things out, it is also a newly contemporary issue under conditions of flexible capitalism and its particular modes of globalization, particularly with regard to global information systems. Classification and its consequences up to now concerning the publication we now have sorting things out. Sorting things out we are much indebted to the members of the nursing interventions project at the university of iowa. We would further like to thank the following iowa team members who have graciously allowed us to interview them. Bowker and susan leigh star axiomathes, 225229 2002. Bowker is professor and director of the evoke lab at the university of california, irvine. Tb was a horrible problem and was difficult to classify. Recent positions include professor of and senior scholar in cyberscholarship at the university of pittsburgh ischool and executive. The authors argue the that 1 classification is a ubiquitous human. It powerfully draws attention to the fact that the materiality of anything action, idea, definition, hammer, gun, or school grade is drawn from the consequences of its situation. Classification and bureaucracy is a fourth strand of science and tech studies along with nature, culture and discourse.
It was a fascinating look at how thoroughly classification systems infest our lives without our even being aware of it, how these. Bowker is professor of informatics at the university of california, irvine. In sorting things out, geoffrey bowker and susan leigh star shed new light on a variety of. Pdf sorting things out download full pdf book download. He moved to uci at the start of 2012, having held the positions of professor and senior scholar in cyberscholarship at the university of pittsburgh school of information. Norman bowker followed the tar road on its sevenmile loop around the lake, then he started all over again, driving slowly, feeling safe inside his fathers big chevy. The preface focuses largely on the nursing classification book system which is the main object under consideration much of sorting things out, however, is enjoyably abstract, i.
542 954 213 1253 1225 615 829 1006 653 219 816 1536 1461 1252 218 1026 364 941 96 1592 804 271 1142 244 668 846 176 866 498 636 640 504 874 807 305 1192 365 416 994 426 484 1335